Time to Take Action
Our Klamath Basin Water Crisis
Upholding rural Americans' rights to grow food,
own property, and caretake our wildlife and natural resources.
 

http://www.heraldandnews.com/articles/2007/02/27/news/local_news/local1.txt
Marsh future uncertain
followed by
Marshland farming doubtful

 Herald and News by Lee Juillerat 2/27/07

H&N file photo Highway 140, in the lower right, is surrounded by water from the dike break on Upper Klamath Lake in June

Landowners haven't decided whether to keep areas of the flooded Caledonia Marsh diked or to breach 100-year-old dikes that separate the marsh from Upper Klamath Lake.

“We're looking at many options, including one where we might breach the dikes intentionally,” said Jon Barkee, a spokesman for the Running Y Ranch Resort.

The resort bought 1,000 of the flooded acres so it could begin repairing the Geary dike which breached last June, flooding the marsh and a portion of the resort's golf course.

The flood waters also temporarily closed and damaged Highway 140.

About 6,000 acres of the Caledonia and Wocus marshes were isolated from Upper Klamath Lake when the Geary family installed dikes in 1905. Another dike prevented flood water from flowing into the Wocus Marsh.

Barkee said Running Y, state and federal officials are involved in determining the long-range future of the Caledonia Marsh. Considerations include water quality in Upper Klamath Lake and impacts on birds, waterfowl and wildlife.

“The impact on wildlife is there no matter what we do,” Barkee said, noting the land reclamation and development of wetlands has benefited various species. “Wildlife have adapted to the changed environment.”

For example, Barkee said, the area has been seasonally flooded to flush out rodents and then drained. During flooding periods, 20 to 30 bald eagles commonly feed on rodents - “The eagles just have a feast.”

Barkee said the diking probably affected Upper Klamath Lake's water quality, noting, “It's been the subject of much debate. The farming activity does add a certain amount of nutrient load.”

Although there is sentiment for permanently breaching the 2-1/2 miles of dikes, there are concerns.

Bureau of Reclamation officials, Barkee said, are concerned about maintaining mandated lake levels for endangered sucker fish, so plans to pump water from the marsh to the lake are being sped up. As water is removed it may be necessary to net suckers from the marsh and and transfer them to the lake.

Running Y officials originally wanted to more slowly remove water because of concerns about the dike and whether more breaks are possible.

Barkee said repairing the breached section was difficult because the gushing water cut a 25-foot deep hole. Instead of repairing the actual break, a new $1 million, 1,000 foot long arc-shaped dike was built.

Temporary dikes also were built along sections of the resort's golf course. Following the break, the fourth hole was completed flooded and the third and fifth holes were partially flooded. If the main dikes are removed, Barkee said dikes will be needed to protect the golf course.

“Initially people liked the water inflow,” he said of the reaction by Running Y residents after the breach, “but as the water receded and it began to smell it became a lot less appealing.”

Permanently breaching the dike system could increase Upper Klamath's water storage, but Barkee said the impact would be minimal because the affected area is shallow and subject to evaporation.
---------------------------------------------------------

Farmer lost crops and farm equipment

 
By LEE JUILLERAT H&N Regional Editor

   Future agricultural use of 2,200 acres marshlands near the Running Y Ranch Resort that was flooded when dikes breached last summer appears doubtful.
   Running Y spokesman Jon Barkee said it appears unlikely that acreage farmed the past century for potatoes, onions, grain and other crops will remain in production.
   “Farming doesn’t seem to be a viable option,” Barkee said.
hole was completed flooded and the third and fifth holes were partially flooded. If the main dikes are removed, Barkee said dikes will be needed to protect the golf course.
   “Initially people liked the water inflow,” he said of the reaction by Running Y residents after the breach, “but as the water receded and it began to smell it became a lot less appealing.”
   Permanently breaching the dike system could increase Upper Klamath’s water storage, but Barkee said the impact would be minimal because the affected area is shallow and subject to evaporation.
“It’s all making it tough for farming. As a business proposition, it's probably not going to be viable. There are several things out there pointing against farming those lands.”
   Ron McGill, who was farming the reclaimed Running Y lands, said he lost a million dollars worth of crops and 14 of his 26 pieces of farm equipment valued at $242,000.
   “I don’t know what to expect,” McGill said of future farming in the reclaimed marsh, noting he has had little contact with Running Y officials.
   “My losses are great,” he said. “We had all of that planted,” mostly in white wheat and some barley. The wheat is sent to Portland and sent to domestic and foreign markets, especially the Middle East, for crackers, pita bread and angel food cake.
   He said crews were able to drive out some tractors before the area flooded while other pieces of farm equipment were floated out. More than half the equipment remains underwater — “I don't think they’ll be any salvage value left,” he said.
   McGill has rented the property since 1976, rotating crops to prevent soil damage. He noted the marsh operation represented about 25 percent of his yearly farming, “So you can see it was a sizable part of our operation, and we had all the investment in it.”

-By Lee Juillerat
 

Home Contact

 

              Page Updated: Thursday May 07, 2009 09:14 AM  Pacific


             Copyright © klamathbasincrisis.org, 2007, All Rights Reserved