http://users.sisqtel.net/armstrng/
Weekly column in Siskiyou Daily News by
Marcia Armstrong, Siskiyou County
Commissioner 4/8/11
Klamath Basin Restoration Agreement Draft Drought Plan
response |
Klamath Basin Restoration Agreement: When the States,
tribes, other Counties, agencies and organizations
signed the Klamath Settlement Agreement, it included
both a process to accomplish dam removal and a process
for “restoration” of the Klamath River basin.
One of the products of the Restoration Agreement (KBRA,)
is a Draft Drought Management Plan.
http://67.199.95.80/Klamath/DraftDroughtPlan2011-02-28.pdf
This was created by a group dubbed
the “lead entity,” comprised of Klamath
Tribes, Karuk Tribe, Yurok Tribe, Upper Klamath Water
Users Association, the Klamath Water and Power Agency (KWAPA,)
the Klamath Basin National Wildlife Refuges, Oregon Water Resources Department,
California Department of Fish and
Game, and Trout Unlimited.
The plan starts out by designating
the Oregon Water Resources Department (OWRD) as
responsible for declaring a drought. This is curious,
because in Siskiyou County, Oregon has no jurisdiction. The National Fish
and Wildlife Foundation (NFWF) is designated to hold the
project funding purse. NFWF is a non-profit, originally
created by Congress. Under the KBRA, the agencies agreed
to redirect some of their funding in their budgets to
the NFWF fund for Klamath restoration. This will be used
to fund the Drought Plan. NFWF will also be made a part
of the “lead entity.”
The Drought Plan would reduce
diversions or use of surface water so that instream
flows can be maintained. The fund would be used to
compensate users for their loss. KWAPA would distribute
money on the Klamath Project and a federal agency
designated by NFWF would distribute the money
off-Project.
In addition, a TAT or
Technical Advisory Team will be given a federal charter.
The TAT will consist of representatives from the U.S.
Fish and Wildlife Service; Bureau of Reclamation; Bureau
of Indian Affairs; NOAA/National Marine Fisheries
Service; USDA; three State of Oregon agencies;
California Dept. of Fish and Game; the Klamath, Yurok
and Karuk Tribes; Humboldt County; KWAPA, a
representative of off-Project irrigators; a
representative of conservation groups; and a
representative of commercial fishing interests. The TAT
will create an Annual Water Management Plan and provide
recommendations to the Secretary of the Interior
concerning “Managed Environmental Water,” storage and
releases down the Klamath River
at Link River Dam. The TAT will also make
recommendations to the State of Oregon on drought conditions.
Within seven days of a
declaration of Drought or Extreme Drought, KWAPA and a
NFWF designated federal agency will determine the amount
and sources of water likely to be available. The TAT
will develop alternative water management scenarios to
protect species of concern. Actions such as voluntary
conservation, use of “new” stored water, use of
groundwater substitution, water transfers and leasing or
forbearance agreements could be used. A sliding scale of
diversion limitations, water use retirement provisions
and land idling could be used so that water can be
managed whereby “no
Klamath
Basin interests bear an
unreasonable portion of burdens imposed.”
In the case of “extreme
drought, under Alternative 1, the “Fish Managers,”
(Klamath Tribes, Yurok Tribe, Karuk Tribe, California
Department of Fish and Game, Oregon
Department of Fish and
Wildlife, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, and the National
Marine Fisheries Service,) will have the power to reduce
the water available for diversion in the Klamath Basin from March – October. Under
Alternative 2, the amount of diversion reductions will
be deferred until more information is known about the
status of fisheries restoration, water quality
improvement, and other actions in the Agreement.
The Siskiyou County
Board of Supervisors has jurisdiction over groundwater.
The Siskiyou County Flood Control and Water Conservation
District was created by Congress under the Klamath
Compact. It has jurisdiction over the entirety of Siskiyou County, with the exception of the Klamath
Project. Included in its responsibilities is: “to
declare the rights in natural flow of any stream or
surface or subterranean supply of waters used or useful
for any purpose of the district or of common benefit of
the lands within the district or to its inhabitants.”
The Klamath Compact between the States of California and
Oregon, ratified by Congress clearly states
that the preference for permitted use of Upper Klamath Basin waters will be: (a) domestic use;
(b) irrigation use; (c) recreational use – including use
for fish and wildlife; (d) industrial use; (e)
hydroelectric power; and (f) other.
The Board and the District recently sent a letter of
concern regarding the Drought Plan, stating that the
proposed plan is in violation of the California
Environmental Quality Act and encroaches upon local
jurisdiction. It declared: “Please be advised that the County of Siskiyou and the Siskiyou County Flood
Control District are, by this correspondence, placing
you on notice that you are not to undertake or implement
any drought plans or activities within their
jurisdictions until such time as appropriate review,
coordination, consultation and necessary approvals have
been obtained.” |