"...it amounts to a major federal power grab over agriculture."

9/29/10 by Bob Waldrop

I have written about this before, but it is important enough to send a
reminder.

Senate bill 510 continues to be a threat to local agriculture in the
United States. A version has passed the US House of Representatives, and
it is now before the US Senate. Fortunately, Senator Tom Coburn of
Oklahoma has placed a hold on the legislation for now, but that could go
away at any moment. NOW is the time to contact your US Senators and ask
them to oppose this legislation.

It would also be helpful, if you are a member of any farm organizations,
for you to contact their legislative people and ask them to lobby
against the bill. Here in Oklahoma, contact Lori Peterson of the
Oklahoma Farm Bureau, at Lori.Peterson@okfb.org or the Oklahoma Farmers
Union (now American Farmers and Ranchers) at legislation@afrmic.com .
Farm Bureau lobbyists are considered particularly effective on ag
issues, so please contact your state Farm Bureau. They almost certainly
will have a website and should have a legislative coordinator.

Below is a version of a letter I have been sending out on this
legislation. Besides the info below, I added info about the Oklahoma
Food Coop. Adapt it for your own circumstances. The 12 points I cribbed
from the Economic Collapse Blog at
http://theeconomiccollapseblog.com/archives/s-510-12-reasons-why-the-food-safety-bill-from-hell-could-be-very-dangerous-for-the-u-s-economy
or http://tinyurl.com/328hbl3 . I suggest you use these 12 points in
your own letter, I tweaked them just a bit. I sent versions of this to
the US senators from Oklahoma and also to the Oklahoma Farm Bureau (I'm
a member). Feel free to pass this on to others who may be interested.

Begin sample letter. . .

Senate Bill 510 is pending in the Senate; a version has passed the US
House of Representatives. While it is ostensibly about "food safety", in
actuality it amounts to a major federal power grab over agriculture.

I am strongly against this bill for these reasons:

#1 All food production facilities in the United States will be required
to register with the U.S. government. No food will be allowed to be
grown, distributed or sold outside this bureaucratic framework unless
the FDA allows it.

#2 Any food that is distributed or sold outside of U.S. government
control will be considered illegal smuggling.

#3 The FDA will hire an army of new inspectors to enforce all of the new
provisions in the bill.

#4 The FDA will be mandated to conduct much more frequent inspections of
food processing facilities.

#5 The fees and paperwork requirements will be ruinously expensive for
small food producers.

#6 S. 510 would place all U.S. food and all U.S. farms under the
Department of Homeland Security in the event of a major "contamination"
or an "emergency". What exactly would constitute a "contamination" or an
"emergency" is anyone's guess.

#7 S. 510 mandates that the FDA facilitate harmonization of American
food laws with Codex Alimentarius, which impinges on US sovereignity.

#8 S. 510 imposes an annual registration fee on any facility that holds,
processes, or manufactures food. It also includes draconian fines for
paperwork infractions of up to $500,000 for a single offense. Just one
penalty like that would drive a small food producer out of business.

#9 S. 510 would give the FDA tremendous discretion to regulate how crops
are grown and how food is produced in the United States. Basically,
farmers will now be forced to farm exactly how the federal government
tells them to. This could be a particular problem for small farmers
selling direct to the public, many of whom are organic farmers because
that is what their market wants to buy. It is feared that the U.S.
government would soon declare that many organic farming methods are
"unsafe" and would outlaw them.

#10 S. 510 will give the FDA the power to impose a quarantine on a
specific geographic area. Basically the FDA would have the power to stop
the movement of all food in an area where a "contamination" has been
identified. This would be very close to being able to declare martial law.

#11 S. 510 will give the FDA the power to conduct warrantless searches
of the business records of small food producers and organic farmers,
even if there has been no evidence at all that a law has been broken.

#12 Many farmers are concerned that S. 510 would eliminate the right to
clean and store seed. Saving and using your own seed is a traditional
frugal practice of many farmers.

There's been some talk that the bill has been amended to make it more
acceptable to small farmers, but I assure you that I am in contact with
hundreds of Oklahoma farmers, many of whom are "small farmers", and they
are united in their opposition. Many are afraid it could put them out of
business I hope you would agree that any legislation that has the
potential of reducing the number of farmers is bad legislation.

Please vote against this bill in the US Senate.

Bob Waldrop
Oklahoma City