A pilot
study aimed at determining the origins of
ocean-caught chinook salmon proved successful
this summer, raising hopes for the eventual
implementation of in-season management
protocols.
Much of
Oregon's offshore commercial fishing has been
closed or restricted this summer to protect
weakened runs of fish from the Klamath River
basin. But the study by Oregon State
University researchers -- done in cooperation
with Oregon commercial fishermen and the
Oregon Salmon Commission -- showed that it is
possible to determine within 24 to 48 hours
the origins of ocean-caught fish.
The next
step of the research, the scientists say, is
to broaden the study to see if fish from
different river systems mingle in the ocean,
or migrate separately as groups.
"The
conclusions reached through genetic testing
were consistent with the results from
traditional coded wire tags we found in some
of the hatchery fish," said Gil Sylvia,
director of OSU's Coastal Oregon Marine
Experiment Station. "What is remarkable is
that the genetic testing has such a rapid
turnaround time; instead of waiting for weeks
or months, you get the results right away. And
it works for wild fish, not just hatchery
fish."
In their
study, the OSU scientists found that about 5
percent of the fish caught off the Oregon
coast originated from the Klamath basin. About
two of every three fish caught during the
research -- which included testing in June,
July, August and September -- came from
California. Most of the others were from
Oregon's rivers, primarily the Columbia and
its tributaries, with the exception of a small
percentage of fish from British Columbia and
Alaska.
The
preliminary research findings underscore the
importance of broadening the study to include
Washington and California, the researchers
point out. During a September meeting in
Portland, the National Marine Fisheries
Service labs in both those states agreed to
work with OSU and other researchers from
Oregon on a joint proposal to expand the
research effort.
"One of
the things we're all interested in learning is
how the distribution of fish is related to
oceanographic data," said Michael Banks, an
OSU salmon geneticist and lead scientist on
the study. "The fishermen are fascinated by
the potential of the data, but for them to
provide that data requires them to stop, and
drop instruments to monitor those conditions,
and check their (global positioning system)
unit.
"It
isn't the most convenient approach," Banks
added. "By the end of the summer, though, we
tested a glider from colleagues at OSU's
College of Oceanic and Atmospheric Sciences
and it followed the fishermen and recorded all
of the data we needed. It was really slick."
During
the research, the OSU scientists tested more
than 1,500 salmon caught off the Oregon coast
and compared their genetic sequencing with
that in a NOAA database of unique genetic
signatures of fish from 200 river basins from
California to Alaska. Klamath fish are
genetically more distinct and can be
identified 98 percent of the time.
But
simply determining whether a fish caught in
the ocean is a Klamath fish, or from some
other river, won't change management decisions
unless more data pinpoints how the fish
congregate and travel.
"We have
one working hypothesis that Klamath fish tend
to be further offshore than fish from most of
the other river systems," Sylvia said, "but we
don't have any firm data to back that up. It
is the kind of hypothesis that would be
valuable to test. This year we determined that
the genetic testing protocols worked. The next
step is to see if we can determine whether
certain fish are more likely to be found
farther north or south, near shore or
offshore, and at what time of year.
"It's a
big project," Sylvia said, "that may require
150 fishing vessels in California, another 100
in Oregon, and a few more in Washington. It is
not trivial. But there is real potential here
for real-time management, and the fishing
community would like to make this happen."
This
summer's research was funded by the Oregon
Watershed Enhancement Board and managed by the
Oregon Salmon Commission. About 50 Oregon
commercial vessels have thus far made nearly
200 fishing trips as part of the study, and
supplied the scientists with more than 1,500
tissue samples and other data.
The OSU
researchers also are keeping track of the
salmon through an onboard electronic
traceability system developed by the
university over the past several years. This
innovative "barcode" system allows commercial
fishermen to log the location, date and time
of the capture, as well as onboard handling
techniques, for every fish captured.
Eventually, such a tool may play a major role
in marketing, according to Michael Morrissey,
director of the OSU Seafood Laboratory in
Astoria, and a principal investigator in the
CROOS project.
"By
identifying the river system through genetics,
and being able to accurately label a fish as
'wild,' the potential exists for fishermen to
brand their product and increase the value to
consumers," Morrissey said. "One such example
is Copper River salmon, which often command
twice the market price of similar fish,
because of the attributes attached to it."
More
information on this project is available at
www.projectCROOS.com