Agency looking at dam options
by STEVE KADEL Herald and
News 11/15/06
They wore T-shirts
proclaiming “Bring the salmon home,”
and carried balloons and signs with
the same message.
Klamath Tribes members
strongly urged a federal panel
Tuesday to restore Klamath River
“We’re hungry for that
fish not only physically, but also
spiritually,” Tribal fisherman Don
Gentry said. “Please return those
fish so we can be the people the
creator intended us to be.”
He spoke during a hearing
on the Federal Energy Regulatory
Commission’s draft Environmental
Impact Statement for relicensing of
Klamath River dams. PacifiCorp
currently operates the dams under a
50-year license that expired in
March.
FERC is considering
options ranging from trucking fish
around dams, which PacifiCorp
favors, to installation of fish
ladders or dam removal. A final EIS
is due in April.
While most who testified
Tuesday supported removing the dams,
Klamath Basin irrigators also spoke
about the need to keep affordable
power rates. They say removing dams
will drive power costs to
unacceptable levels.
“We depend on low-cost
power to keep our communities
whole,” said Scott Seus, the Klamath
Water Users Association’s power
committee chairman. “Today, more
than ever, low-cost power is
essential to irrigated agriculture.”
He and others said the
Klamath Reclamation Project benefits
the Klamath River, and therefore the
salmon, by returning almost all of
the diverted water used for
irrigation.
“Without the Klamath
irrigation project and the water
stored within, there would be
inconsistent flows that would result
in less power production and a
volatile ecosystem,” Seus said.
Klamath Water Users
Association board member Bob Gasser
and Project irrigator John Crawford
echoed Seus’ comments about the
importance of affordable power.
Crawford also noted the
Project pushes water from the Lost
River watershed into the Klamath
River, benefiting the Tulelake
National Wildlife Refuge in the
process.
Tribes members emphasized
the 1864 treaty signed by the U.S.
government gave Indians the right to
fish area streams forever. They
added that a promise by
California-Oregon Power Co. to
install fish ladders at the Klamath
River’s first dam went unfulfilled.
“Where’s the justice?”
asked Klamath Tribes member Gerald
Skelton Jr. “Why is it always our
folks who have to pay for someone
else’s economic glory?”
Spayne Martinez, a 15-yearold
Chiloquin High School sophomore,
urged the dams be removed.
“I view all rivers as
blood to the world,” she said. “The
people who depend on the salmon have
suffered too long.”
Antone Minthorn, chairman
of the board of trustees for the
Confederated Tribes of Umatilla,
also addressed FERC representatives.
“We are not against
economic development,” he said.
“It’s just that the fish were our
economy.”
Joe Hobbs, vice chairman
of the Klamath Tribes, noted the
salmon historically returned to the
Upper Klamath Basin. Construction of
dams that prevented those runs from
continuing is “a travesty that needs
to be rectified,” he said.
Phil Tupper mentioned
something that could satisfy the
needs of salmon and irrigators.
“If you really want to
solve this problem you need deep,
coldwater storage,” he said.
H&N photo by Andrew Mariman
Destiny Summers, 10, backs efforts
on Tuesday to restore salmon.
H&N photo by Andrew Mariman
Spirit Riveria, 3, right, and Alway
Crain, 4, take a breather from a
public meeting about dam relicensing
at the Shilo Inn Tuesday.