SHANGHAI, China -- The list
of Chinese food exports
rejected at American ports
reads like a chef's
nightmare: pesticide-laden
pea pods, drug-laced
catfish, filthy plums and
crawfish contaminated with
salmonella.
Yet it took a much more
obscure item, contaminated
wheat gluten, to focus U.S.
public attention on a very
real and frightening fact:
China's chronic food safety
woes are now an
international concern.
In
recent weeks, scores of cats
and dogs in America have
died of kidney failure
blamed on eating pet food
containing gluten from China
that was tainted with
melamine, a chemical used in
plastics, fertilizers and
flame retardants. Humans
aren't believed to be at
risk, but the incident has
sharpened concerns about
China's food exports and the
limited ability of U.S.
inspectors to catch problem
shipments.
"This really shows the risks
of food purity problems
combining with international
trade," said Michiel Keyzer,
director of the Center for
World Food Studies at
Amsterdam's Vrije
Universiteit.
Just as with manufactured
goods, exports of meat,
produce and processed foods
from China have soared in
recent years, prompting
outcries from foreign farm
sectors that are feeling
pinched by low Chinese
prices.
Worried about losing access
to foreign markets and stung
by tainted food products
scandals at home, China has
in recent years tried to
improve inspections, with
limited success.
The problems the government
faces are legion. Pesticides
and chemical fertilizers are
used in excess to boost
yields, and harmful
antibiotics are widely
administered to control
disease in seafood and
livestock. Rampant
industrial pollution risks
introducing heavy metals
into the food chain.
Farmers have used the
cancer-causing industrial
dye Sudan Red to boost the
value of their eggs and fed
an asthma medication to pigs
to produce leaner meat. In a
case that galvanized the
public's and government's
attention, shoddy infant
formula with little or no
nutritional value has been
blamed for causing severe
malnutrition in hundreds of
babies and killing at least
12.
China's Health Ministry
reported almost 34,000
food-related illnesses in
2005, with spoiled food
accounting for the largest
number, followed by
poisonous plants or animals
and the use of agricultural
chemicals.
With China increasingly
intertwined in global trade,
Chinese exporters are paying
a price for unsafe
practices. Excessive
antibiotic or pesticide
residues have caused bans in
Europe and Japan on Chinese
shrimp, honey and other
products. Hong Kong blocked
imports of turbot last year
after inspectors found
traces of malachite green, a
possibly cancer-causing
chemical used to treat
fungal infections, in some
fish.
One source of the problem is
China's fractured farming
sector, comprised of small
landholdings that make
regulation difficult,
experts said.
Small farms ship to market
with little documentation.
Testing of the safety and
purity of farm products,
such as milk, is often
haphazard, hampered by fuzzy
lines of authority among
regulators. Only about 6
percent of agricultural
products were considered
pollution-free in 2005, and
safer, better-quality food
officially stamped as
"green" accounts for just 1
percent of the total,
according to figures
compiled by the U.S.
Department of Agriculture.
For foreign importers, the
answer is to know your
suppliers and test
thoroughly, food industry
experts said.
"You just have to hope that
your system is strong enough
and your producers are
careful enough," said Todd
Meyer, China director for
the U.S. Grains Council.
Health Ministry officials
acknowledge problems, but
have described scandals such
as the 2004 baby formula
deaths as isolated
incidents. Neither the
ministry nor the State
Administration of Quality
Supervision, Inspection and
Quarantine, responsible for
overall food safety
standards, responded to
questions submitted to them
in writing, as requested.
During the past 25 years,
Chinese agricultural exports
to the U.S. surged nearly
twentyfold, to $2.26 billion
last year, led by poultry
products, sausage casings,
shellfish, spices and apple
juice.
Inspectors from the U.S.
Food and Drug Administration
are able to inspect only a
tiny percentage of the
millions of shipments that
enter the U.S. each year.
Even so, shipments from
China were rejected at the
rate of about 200 a month
this year, the largest from
any country, compared with
about 18 for Thailand and 35
for Italy, also big
exporters to the U.S.,
according to data posted on
the FDA's website.
Chinese products are bounced
for containing pesticides,
antibiotics and other
potentially harmful
chemicals, and false or
incomplete labeling that
sometimes omits the
producer's name.