New "PIT tag" data analysis
developed by NOAA Fisheries should better allow
the agency to calculate survival rates of adult
salmon and steelhead as they attempt their
spawning journey up through the Columbia and
Snake rivers' system of dams and reservoirs.
The preliminary spreadsheet
analysis has shown that survival from one
hydroelectric dam to the next is averaging 98
percent and better in recent years, a NOAA
Fisheries scientist told the Northwest Power and
Conservation Council Tuesday during its meeting
in Boise.
"That's real high survival; most
people would agree those are good numbers to
have," said Ritchie Graves, acting branch chief
of NOAA Fisheries' regional Hydropower Division
in Portland. NOAA Fisheries is the federal
agency that implements the Endangered Species
Act for salmon and steelhead in the Northwest.
The estimates are "minimum
estimates of direct survival from point to
point" that are adjusted to take into account
harvests and fish that stray from their
anticipated course, Graves said. His analysis
plots detections of passive integrated
transponder tags that are inserted in many fish
before they migrate to the ocean as juveniles. A
network of PIT-tag detectors installed at key
mainstem dams since 2000 allow researchers to
monitor the fish heading both downstream and
upstream.
The new technique for estimating
adult "conversion rates" -- survival through
mainstem reaches -- is being developed by NOAA
for possible use in a new Federal Columbia River
Power System biological opinion that is due for
completion in February. The BiOp judges whether
the federal hydrosystem and its operations
jeopardize the survival of salmon and steelhead
that are listed under the Endangered Species
Act.
The "quickie" analysis was
presented to the FCRPS BiOp remand Policy Work
Group last month, Graves said. The court-ordered
remand of a 2004 FCRPS BiOp is being carried out
in collaboration with Northwest states and
tribes.
The analysis will be fine-tuned
in the coming months. The harvest adjustments,
as an example, must be further researched to
assure that they are all-inclusive.
"We're going to keep moving
ahead," Graves of the attempt to better assess
the dams' share of salmon mortality.
Graves presented results for
adult chinook and steelhead survival between
Bonneville and McNary dams, between McNary and
Lower Granite Dam and between Bonneville and
Lower Granite. Bonneville is the first dam the
fish pass on the lower Columbia and Snake
River's Lower Granite is the eighth and final
dam fish climb. The analysis also charts Upper
Columbia adult fishes' progress from Bonneville
to McNary, McNary to Wells Dam and from
Bonneville to Wells.
The analysis looks at returns
from 2002 through 2006.
Wild and hatchery-reared spring
chinook released as juveniles above Lower
Granite Dam experienced about 99 percent
survival between Bonneville and McNary dams when
they returned as adults, and 99-100 percent
survival between McNary and Lower Granite dams,
Graves said. The survival of Snake River summer
and fall chinook between McNary and Lower
Granite dams, and for upper Columbia steelhead
between McNary and Wells dams, averaged 97-98
percent.
"There's kind of a consistent
pattern here," Graves said of the high survival
estimates.
By detecting the passing fish
with electronic signals, information is obtained
instantly and without having to trap and handle
the adult salmon. In the past, the survival
information was obtained with dedicated studies
in which shorter-lived radio tags were inserted
in adult fish.
The PIT tag technology allows
researchers "to get conversion rates a lot
quicker, and a lot cheaper" than the labor
intensive radio tag technology, according to Jim
Ruff, the NPCC's mainstem passage and river
operations chief.
Council Chair Tom Karier said the
results are encouraging.
"At least the adult salmon do not
appear to have difficulty with the dams," Karier
said. "This is good news if we are only losing 1
or 2 percent of the fish migrating upstream."
Council Member Judi Danielson of
Idaho said the results bode well for salmon and
steelhead returning to that state:
"We hear so much about the impact
of the dams, but here is data that shows we have
done so much to improve passage survival through
the hydrosystem; now it is time to sharpen our
focus on improving fish survival in other areas,
particularly harvest, which has been 9 percent
or more on these fish between dams."
Because the tags identify fish by
the location where they were released, tagged
fish can be tracked through most of their river
migration. Some fish can pass undetected at one
dam or another, but the accuracy of calculating
conversion rates is improving as the detection
equipment becomes more sophisticated.