Bush Adm.: "Fish Don't Need Water"
Something Rotten in Klamath

http://www.mapcruzin.com/news/bush050303a.htm

Fair Use Statement

Source: Counterpunch

CounterPunch October 2, 2002

Bush Adm.: "Fish Don't Need Water"
Something Rotten in Klamath

by JEFFREY ST. CLAIR

More than 35,000 fish lay dead in the bed of the Klamath River and the death count continues to rise. These are not just any fish. They are wild salmon, both coho and chinook, the very totems of the Northwest. They suffocated from lack of cool water.

KBC:  These were mostly Trinity River hatchery Chinook salmon, where up to 90% of the Trinity is diverted to the Sacramento River in the Central Valley of California.

As the death toll mounted, Gale Norton, the grim boss of the Interior Department, acted befuddled and suggested that the die-off in these foul waters was a strange natural mystery.

KBC:  Secretary Gale Norton encouraged the highest ranked scientists in the world to study this phenomena, the National Academy of Science.  Thank you Secretary Norton for choosing to find out science-based answers.

But there's no need to call in a fish coroner. The slaughter in the Klamath River was a deliberate act, connived at by the White House, the Interior Department and the gang of Klamath River basin irrigators who have run riot down in southern Oregon for these many years.

KBC:  That statement is true--the environmental groups, California Fish and Game, and the Tribes were not inclined to 'call in a fish coroner' or check water temperatures for over a week, so any evidence of drug-lab poisons on the River or other pollutants or poisons could not be detected.  "There are fish floating in every eddy," says Mike Belchick, a biologist with the Yurok Tribe. "Eyes popping out. Guts coming out. Scores of dead fish with moss on them. It makes me want to cry."

KBC:  Fish die every year after they spawn, and fish die-offs are not uncommon. Yes, they stink and rot and add nutrients to the river to help feed the salmon smelts and other wildlife

Now water is being released from the dams upstream near Klamath Lake. But it's far too late and will do little more than flush the stinking corpses downstream, along with the daily brew of pesticides, cowshit, and fertilizer that accounts for the normal effluent from the fields of the Klamath Basin.

KBC:  According to Dr Ken Rybost, scientist for U of O extension office, there is more nitrogen in the water now since over 90,000 acres have been taken out of farm and pasture lands and made into wetlands.  Also, waterfowl poop has more nitrogen than cow poop.  As for fertilizers and pesticides, according to Tulelake USFWS recent  manager Phil Norton:  There have been no (NOT EVEN ONE) cases of effected birds or fish or water from farm pesticides or fertilizers.

Off course, it's the big fish kills that grab the headlines. And this was an unprecedented one: more than 30 percent of the entire salmon population of the Klamath wiped out in a single blow. Tribal leaders say there's no precedent for the death toll in history or myth.

KBC:  2002 had a record run of Chinook in the Klamath River.  Tribal and commercial fishermen said that there were so many that they could not even sell them.  The fishing take limit was raised.

But the salmon of the Klamath River, once one of the mightiest runs on earth, have been dying out for decades in a slow, steady slide toward extinction.

KBC:  Then why was there a record run of salmon last summer

The gory front-page photos of mass death send the wrong message, shocking, but oddly comforting to those responsible. They suggest a sudden catastrophic event, a singular tragic mistake. In fact, the salmon of the Klamath River, which flows some 200 miles from southern Oregon to the northern California coast, are the victim of a system that has conspired against them since the 1940s, at least.

KBC:  We farmers were appalled at how the die-off was handled, especially when the waters were not tested for over a week.  We were appalled when over 62,000 AF of water was demanded of the Klamath Project in 2002, so we pumped our untested aquifer to send water down the river.  We were forced to send warm water, demanded by the tribes.  According to fishery scientist Dave Vogel, the water temperatures of this untimely-demanded water were lethal temperatures for fish.

It is a system of industrial agriculture, backed by the federal government, that has been given free reign to dewater the Klamath River to irrigate cheap croplands of alfalfa, potatoes and onions. More than half the annual income from these farms and ranches come from federal crop supports, but apparently that doesn't obligate them to save the fish.

There are absolutely NO subsidies on alfalfa, potatoes, onions, horseradish, garlic, or mint.  This is some of the most fertile land in the United States.  By the way, the Klamath Basin grows over 30% of our nation's horseradish.

The fact that the Yurok, Hoopa and Klamath tribes enjoy treaty rights to the river's salmon and depend on those fish for food, income and ceremonial rites has meant nothing to the masters of the river.

KBC:  How absurd!  A record run of fish, the Tribal fishermen can't sell them because there are so many, the take limit is raised, the price is cheap, the farmers have gone through hell from bankruptcies and endless litigation from having their water taken in 2001 because of NON-PEER-REVIEWED by USFWS, our aquifer is damaged...the list goes on. If we were the 'masters of the river' we would not have sent huge-unprecedented flows of warm water down the river because of contrived science.

This is story of a death foretold. Biologists have warned since the 1970s that big changes in river flows were needed to avert extinction of coho and Chinook salmon and the Klamath River suckerfish.

For eight years, Clinton and Babbitt did little for the salmon. Every proposal was a half-measure, which denounced by the Klamath irrigators, and followed by a quick retreat. The salmon stocks declined, the delicate coho, which thrives in cold, clear water, tottered toward extinction.

By the time the Bush crowd took office there was no margin for error. A nasty drought in the summer of 2001 exacerbated the problem. When federal biologists called for the Bureau of Reclamation to dribble out more water for the fish, the Klamath farmers threw a fit. They organized a so-called "bucket brigade," a raid on the dams and pumps that diverted water into their parched fields. Threats were leveled against federal biologists, environmentalists and Indians.

KBC:  They did not 'dribble out more water'. Klamath Lake was full, the river was so full that it hampered mining, and they completely shut off water to the Klamath Basin farmers.  This was water stored in a Project that farmers built and paid for, for irrigation.  The river could not be this high without the Project. This was water deeded to the veterans who were given homesteads for their service in the World Wars. There were no raids on dams or pumps. The four times the "headgates" were opened by non-violent civil disobedience , not one drop of water made it through the system of canals to one acre of parched farm land in the Klamath Project. Also, no threats were ever made to any federal employee, environmentalist, or Indian Tribal member.

The sheriff of Klamath Falls joined in the fun, saying he wouldn't arrest any of the irrigators for monkeywrenching the water diversions. One of his deputies, Lt. Jack Redfield, even said at a rally of ranchers and farmers that he might tolerate some violence against Oregon environmentalists. Then he named two potential targets: Andy Kerr and Wendell Wood. "It won't take much from Andy Kerr or Wendell Wood or their like to spark an extremely violent response," said Redfield. "I am talking about rioting, homicides, destruction of property.

KBC:  Lt. Jack Redfield did not say that he would tolerate violence. He only said that violence could be a possible consequences of exterminating an entire community's economy and ecosystem.

Environmentalist who engage in tree sits and roadblocks to stop timber sale are now treated by like terrorists in several states, including Oregon and Idaho. Only last week, three Oregon forest activists were arrested on charges of torching logging equipment. They now face the possibility of 20 years in jail and $500,000 in fines.

KBC:  Good!  We do not believe in terrorism of any kind; whether it is destroying the ecosystem and wildlife in our refuges or in our canals which had historically never gone dry; or destroying equipment.

But the Klamath water bullies are accustomed to having their way. They convinced the federal government to turn over almost half of the Klamath National Wildlife Refuge to them, which is now farmed at the expense of native wildlife. They've gotten away with destroying federal property, killing endangered species and threatening federal officials. Instead of rebukes and arrests, Oregon Senator Gordon Smith, the Republican frozen food magnate, called them heroes. They even got reimbursed for their trouble to the tune of $4 million.

KBC:  The only fish kills in the Klamath Basin have been during high-water-level years in Upper Klamath Lake; never, ever on low water years.  We believe is historical records and  'peer-reviewed' science, and facts. There is no farming on or in the "Klamath National Wildlife Refuge --- it’s located in the Tulelake and Lower Klamath Lake refuges. Farming in the lower refuges feeds the wildlife over 30 million pounds of food. The only federal property destroyed was a few links of chain, and one padlock.

The national press corps viewed this summer-long riot as a kind of quaint rural dust up, not much different than a fractious rodeo. At the time, the irrigators had conned the press into reporting that the water releases were all about saving the endangered suckerfish, a decidedly unsexy species also faced with extinction. The word salmon rarely made an appearance. In fact, the entire river system is a mess, on the brink of ecological collapse.

Last spring, the Bush crowd decided that the Klamath farmers could have all the water they wanted, regardless of the consequences for salmon. In a March ceremony, Gale Norton presided over the diversion of water to the irrigators. The tribes and environmentalists showed up to protest. But it was to no avail.

This summer was one of the driest and hottest on record. Biologists and tribes pleaded with Norton to release more water for the salmon. She refused. The Bush administration took the surrealistic position that fish don't need water. It's a position they still cling to. "If there is some evidence it's a problem, we'll take a hard look at it," said John Keys, director of the Bureau of Reclamation, only last week. "We've been saying since last year that we're not sure more water would do the fish any good."

KBC:  Again, 62,000 AF was demanded of the project irrigators for ‘tribal trust’....that's why wells went dry, from pumping our aquifer.

By August the temperature of the depleted waters of the Klamath River exceeded 70 degrees, a number considered lethal for migratory salmon. As the chinook and coho ascended the broiling river, they became disoriented, lethargic and began to perish from a host of diseases. Federal fisheries biologist Tom Shaw told his superiors that river conditions were "extremely lethal." His warnings were ignored.

"They played Russian roulette with our fish and our fish lost," says Troy Fletcher of the Yurok Tribe.

KBC: And again, diversions of up to 90% of the cooler Trinity River water to the California Central Valley and the Sacramento River for farmers, cities, and hydroelectric power, and demanding more Klamath Basin water, at lethal temperatures for fish, are not exactly going to help fish, and we certainly never encouraged that fatal plan.


It wasn't so much a game, as a gameplan. All along the irrigators had plotted the final doom of the salmon, which were a looming impediment to their increasingly frail economic condition. With the troublesome fish out of the way, they believe that their precious system of dams, pumps and irrigation ditches will be safe from the lawsuits of the environmentalists and the tribes.

Now the dead fish are being scooped up with bulldozers and trucked to a plant in Eureka, California where they will be rendered into fertilizer and no doubt end up back on some of the very fields that lead to their demise.

Somebody should swipe a few of those carcasses from the banks of the Klamath, ship them to Washington and stuff them under Gale Norton's front porch, so that the unique odor of rotting salmon will haunt her the rest of her days.