Barron Bail, BLM area manager, and
John Crawford, Wood River committee member and
local farmer, comment on Wood River acquisition
article of
July 16, 2003.
From BLM's Barron Bail:
I read your account of the recent tour of various
wetland/storage projects
in the Klamath Basin. I found it very interesting,
but I want to correct
one statement in the article. In the article you
indicate the Wood River
Ranch, now the Wood River Wetlands, was acquired for
storage. That is
incorrect. I was the BLM Area Manager when the
proposal for BLM to
purchase the ranch was first presented to the agency
and can shed some
light on why BLM was asked to acquire the property.
The Klamath Basin Water Resources Advisory Committee
(KBWRAC) approached
the BLM in late August/early September 1992 and
proposed that the BLM
purchase the Wood River Ranch. The KBWRAC was a
group representing
diverse interests appointed by the Klamath County
Commissioners and the
Supervisors of Modoc and Siskyou County. It is my
understanding that
originally they wanted the Wood River Ranch acquired
to test theories that
wetland restoration would improve water quality in
Klamath Lake. An
earlier proposal involved the U.S. Fish and Wildlife
Service as the
managing agency, but the KBWRAC couldn’t reach
consensus over USFWS
management. At that point the BLM was suggested as
an alternative land
management agency to acquire the property.
The note I sent my boss the day after meeting with
the KBWRAC includes the
following:
“Their proposal is for the BLM to use
money planned for
acquisition in the Steens to acquire the
Wood River Ranch in
Klamath County. The WRR is 3,000 acres on
the north end of
Agency Lake, between the Wood River and
Seven Mile Creek. The
WRR owner apparently has terminal cancer
and would like to move
quickly to sell the property.
The ranch is presently pasture land and if
acquired by BLM they
would want us to convert the land back
into a natural marsh for
the benefit of water quality and the
endangered sucker fish.
Scientific studies would be strongly
encouraged. If possible
they would also like to see other uses
like recreation take
place.”
At that time water storage was less of an issue then
it is currently.
While there may have been discussion of storage, I
don’t remember it, and I
can’t find it mentioned in my notes. The first
project I remember that
targeted storage was the Bureau of Reclamation
acquisition next to the Wood
River Wetland.
There was discussion about how the BLM would involve
local interests in
planning, and a very active debate over the question
of leaving the dikes
in place and doing active management, or removing
the dikes and letting
nature take over. To resolve this issue BLM
committed to a very open
planning process with significant local
involvement. The plan that
resulted from that effort defined the goals you
listed in your article.
That plan has also directed BLM management of the
Wood River Ranch.
I hope this information is useful to you. I
consider the years I spent
living in the Klamath Basin and working with the
people of the Basin as a
highlight of my life. As you can tell, I still try
and follow issues in
the Basin, and I hope that solution that meets the
needs of all the
residents of the Basin can be found.
Barron Bail.
From committee member and
Tulelake farmer John Crawford:
John Crawford said that the goals for
Wood River Ranch, in 1993, were:
"1. improve water quality with wetland
filtration
2. monitor those lands extensively to prove
water quality by wetland filtration
3. additional storage
4 improved habitat for suckers
5. allow no net loss of private land.
None of these goals were achieved!" |